Mahoningtown Pizzeria Menu

Mahoningtown Pizzeria Menu

Mangino’s “Grab-and-Go” | Sit Down Pizzeria - 106 N Liberty St. New Castle, PA 16102
(724) 652-7621

Since 1979, here is where our hand-pinched crust original & specialty pizza recipes and specialties began.

Please note that menu items and prices may differ depending on the location.

A pizza sitting in a box on top of the floor.

Original Pizzas

All Classics are served on our signature crust with a hand-pinched edge. Look for these ** that denote our Original Recipes!

{The Original Pizza or Homestyle Pizza}**

Our signature crust topped with the Mangino family’s sweetest secret (kept for over 75 years) our tomato sauce recipe and topped with melted Real® provolone and Romano cheeses. Make it Homestyle with no provolone and extra Real® Romano cheese.

{ Poor Man’s Pizza }**

Skip the red sauce and enjoy a variation on an old favorite— white pizza. A unique blend of Italian spices, olive oil, and Real® romano and provolone cheese all atop our signature crust.

Single Slice

2.75

Personal Pan Pizza (4 slices)

7.95

12” Round (6 slices)

12.25

14” Round (8 slices)

14.60

Sicilian (12 slices)

18.50

Extra Toppings

Provolone Cheese, Pepperoni, Mild Italian Sausage, Italian Ham, Bacon, Green Peppers, Mild Peppers, Sliced Mushrooms, Sliced Onions, Sliced Black Olives, Extra Sauce.

1.95 per item on 12“ and 2.25 per item on 14” Rounds and 2.95 per item on Sicilian

{ Brier Hill Pizza }**

The authentic Italian pizza made famous in Youngstown’s Little Italy. This local pizza is reinvented with our original crust, a generous amount of Mangino’s Red Sauce, sliced bell peppers and extra REAL® Romano cheese.

Single Slice

3.25

Personal Pan Pizza (4 slices)

11.50

12” Round (6 slices)

12.95

14” Round (8 slices)

15.50

Sicilian (12 slices)

19.95
Thin-crust pizza topped with sliced tomatoes

Specialty Pizzas

Our specialty selections are served on our signature crust with a hand-pinched edge.

{ Fresh Tomato Pizza }**

Any way you slice it we have the freshest tomatoes from the market. These garden beauties are brushed with olive oil, Italian spices, and topped with Real® provolone and Romano cheese on our signature crust.

{ Zucchini Pizza }**

Our baked zucchini and egg is a traditional Italian favorite. Thinly sliced seasoned zucchini spiraled around our signature crust. Topped with Italian spices and drizzled ranch dressing and then we add grated Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

{ Meatball Pizza }**

We’ve taken our Original Pizza and topped it with lots-and-lots of mini meatballs and grated Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

{ Marinated Onion Pizza }**

We’ve taken our Poor Man’s Pizza and topped it with marinated onions, Italian sausage, hot peppers and Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

{Eggplant Pizza}

It all starts with our secret blend of herbs, our tomato sauce and top generously with the Italian hand-breaded, pan-friend slivers of eggplant and Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

{Mixed Vegetable Pizza}

Broccoli, cauliflower and special blend of spices covered in a delicious white sauce and topped with cheddar and provolone cheeses.

{ Buffalo Chicken Pizza }**

It all starts with our creamy buffalo sauce on our shell with grilled Chicken and Romano and Real® provolone cheese.

Single Slice

3.25

Personal Pan Pizza

11.50

12” Round (6 slices)

15.95

14” Round (8 slices)

18.25

Sicilian (12 slices)

24.50

Gluten Free Crust

Upon Request
A plate of meatball sliders topped with melted cheese and marinara sauce, served on a dark rectangular dish. Text reads "Mangino's Meatball Sliders.
A close up of some food on a table
Sliced stromboli with melted cheese and peppers
Spinach and pepperoni pinwheels with marinara

Specialties & Appetizers

All specialties are great with Mangino’s Family Sauce.

{ Spinach Roll }**

Steamed, seasoned spinach and grated Real® Romano rolled in our pizza dough and baked golden brown.

{ Pepperoni Roll }**

Sliced pepperoni and grated Real® provolone rolled in our family dough and baked golden brown.

Small

3.50

Large

7.50

{Stromboli}

A baked, authentic Italian specialty layered with flavor in every bite—filled with pepperoni, sausage, hot peppers, sauce, and grated Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

Small

8.95

Large

16.00

{Sausage Pie}

A Mangino favorite! We warn you, once you’ve had a bite, you’re hooked. This thick slice is pure baked satisfaction—filled with sweet Italian sausage, egg, Italian seasoning, melted Real® provolone and Romano cheese.

Single Slice

7.50

{ Mangino’s Meatball Sliders } **

Our Original Garlic Knots stuffed with a meatball, Mangino’s Red Sauce and REAL® Romano and Provolone cheeses.

2 Sliders

4.85

4 Sliders

9.25

6 Sliders

12.95
A plate of chicken wings with garlic on the side.

{ Wings }

{ Wings }

Deep-fried to perfection and topped with the sauce of your choice. Available in MILD, HOT, BBQ or GARLIC sauce. Try our NEW Sweet Thai Chili sauce.

10 pieces

14.95

20 pieces

25.95

45 pieces

49.95

90 pieces

93.95
A sandwich cut in half on top of a black plate.

Dugout – Stuffed Loaf

Our toasted Italian bread loaf is stuffed with your choice of Meatball or Cheese and topped with a bread lid—an item known to stuff those with a big appetite.

{ Meatball Dugout }**

Stuffed with mammoth sized meatballs, Real® provolone cheese and Manginos' Family Sauce
10.95

{ Yucca }**

This cheese stands alone…with Real® provolone cheese, and Manginos' Family Sauce
9.50
A sandwich cut in half on top of a plate.

Toasted Sandwiches

Each Italian sandwich is toasted to golden brown perfection and stuffed with hearty goodness.

{Italian Supreme}

Original Mangino’s recipe stacked with 2 layers of classic Italian deli meats: Genoa Salami, PrimA Porta Hot + Spicy Ham, and Real® Provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with shredded lettuce, sliced tomato and a side of Italian dressing.

{Capicola Ham & Provolone}

Original Mangino’s recipe stacked with PrimA Porta Ham, and Real® Provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with shredded lettuce, sliced tomato and a side of Italian dressing.

{Genoa Salami & Provolone}

Original Mangino’s recipe stacked with Genoa Salami, and Real® Provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with shredded lettuce, sliced tomato and a side of Italian dressing.

{Sausage Sandwich}

Hearty mild Italian Sausage, melted Real® Provolone cheese with Mangino’s Family Sauce.

9.50

{Sausage Deluxe}

Hearty mild Italian Sausage sautéed with sweet onions and green bell peppers, open-face melted Real® Provolone cheese — Mangino’s old style recipe! with or without Mangino’s Family Sauce.

{Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich}

Breaded sliced eggplant with Mangino's Family sauce and melted Real® Provolone and Romano cheese.

10.75

{Philly Steak Sandwich}

Grilled Steak topped with sautéed onions, green and red bell peppers, and melted Real® Provolone cheese.

{Grilled Lamb Sandwich}

Grilled Lamb topped with sautéed onions, hot peppers, and melted Real® Provolone cheese.

12.95

Add French Fries to any sandwich for an additional

2.50

A bowl of pasta covered in sauce and cheese.

PASTA CLASSICS

Served with (2) fresh Baked Garlic Knots

and One (1) Cup of Soup – OR – One (1) Small Italian Salad

{ Penne or Spaghetti & Meatballs }

Single serving of real Italian penne pasta tossed with Mangino’s Red Sauce and topped with two hearty meatballs. Each order served with 2 garlic knots and choice of soup or small Italian salad.

Single Serving

14.95

{ Cavatelli & Meatballs }

Single serving of real Italian cavatelli pasta tossed with Mangino’s Red Sauce and topped with two hearty meatballs. Each order served with 2 garlic knots and choice of soup or small Italian salad.

Single Serving

16.45
A close up of lasagna on a plate

Pasta Specialties

Served with Two (2) Garlic Knots & Choice of Soup – OR – Small Italian Salad

{ Homemade Lasagna } **

Layers of pasta stuffed high with Ricotta, grated REAL® Romano and Provolone cheeses, with layers of Mangino’s Red Sauce and specially seasoned ground beef for a hearty single serving of authentic Italian lasagna. Each order served with 2 garlic knots and choice of soup or small Italian salad.

Single Serving

16.95
Two bowls of soup on a white plate

Soups

Our soups are made fresh daily from fresh ingredients.

{Momma’s Italian Wedding Soup}

The Italian version of chicken soup. This hearty soup is filled with mini-meatballs, diced chicken breast, escarole, celery, carrots, pastina in a base of homemade chicken broth.

{ Chicken Pastina Soup }

The Chicken Pastina soup is filled with diced chicken breast, celery, carrots, and pastina in a base of homemade chicken broth.

Cup

5.25

Pint

7.25

Quart

13.25
A plate of salad with lettuce, tomatoes and olives.

Classic Salads

All salads are made fresh every day.
Your choice of dressing: Mangino’s Balsamic**, Ranch, or Italian.

{ Garden Salad }

Romaine lettuce topped with black olives, tomatoes, and shredded provolone cheese.

11.95

Extra dressing 4 oz. for 1.25

A white bowl filled with salad and french fries.

Hometown Salads

All salads are made fresh every day.
Your choice of dressing: Mangino’s Balsamic**, Ranch, or Italian.

{ Grilled Chicken Salad }

Grilled sliced chicken strips over crisp greens of romaine, black olives, tomatoes, and shredded Real® Provolone cheese. Then topped with french fries and served with your choice of dressing.

{ Steak Salad }

Layers of tender crisp greens of romaine, black olives, tomatoes and shredded REAL® Provolone cheese. Then topped with grilled sliced steak and french fries. Served with your choice of dressing.

{ Italian Chef Salad }

The Italian deli-inspired salad is made from tender crisp greens of romaine, black olives and tomatoes, then topped with shredded REAL® Provolone cheese, ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, and mild banana peppers. Served with your choice of dressing—we suggest our Mangino’s Balsamic Dressing!

{ Lamb Salad }

A hometown favorite of grilled sliced lamb and fries on top of tender crisp greens of romaine, black olives, tomatoes and shredded REAL® Provolone cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.

Grilled Chicken Salad

14.95

Steak Salad

15.95

Italian Chef Salad

15.95

Lamb Salad

17.95

Extra dressing 4 oz. for 1.25

A bowl of meatballs and some rolls on the table

Side Orders

{ Mozzarella Sticks }

Five breaded and deep-fried Mozzarella served with a side of Mangino’s Family Sauce
7.50

{ Hot Cheese Balls }

Breaded and deep-fried Provolone Balls served with a side of Mangino’s Family Sauce
7.50

{ French Fries }

Small

4.95

Large

7.95

{ Mangino’s Family Tomato Sauce }

Mangino family’s sweetest secret—kept for over 75 years—our tomato sauce recipe. Perfect as a dipping sauce for our specialties, garlic knots and pasta trays!

Small (4oz)

1.50

Large (8oz)

3.00

Pint (16oz)

5.95

Quart (32oz)

11.75

{ Mangino’s Meatballs }

One delicious Large Meatball

2.50

Side of 3 Large Meatballs

7.50
A burrito with some black olives on top of it.
A pile of cookies with different colored sprinkles.

Desserts

{ Cannoli }

Crispy cannoli shells stuffed with a filling made from sweet creamy ricotta blended with semisweet mini chocolate chips and dusted with powdered sugar for a favorite Italian dessert.

Small Cannoli – Single

2.65

Small Cannoli – 1/2 Dozen (6)

12.95

Small Cannoli – Dozen (12)

21.95

Large Cannoli – Single

5.65

Large Cannoli – Four (4)

19.95

{Italian cookie Sampler}

Assortment of New York Style Italian Cookies

Small

6.55

Large

12.95

{Tiramisu }

The classic Italian dessert. This slice is made with ladyfinger pastries dipped in coffee, whipped egg yolks, sugar, mascarpone and dusted with cocoa powder.
6.50

{Mangino's Fried Dough }

Our signature dough, deep-fried to perfection and topped with sugar.
5.95
Close-up of a tomato pizza topped with slices of tomato, melted cheese, and a sprinkle of spices. Text in the bottom right corner reads "Tomato Pizza.
A loaf of bread hollowed out, filled with meatballs covered in marinara sauce and melted cheese, with a slice of bread beside it. Text reads "Original Stuffed Meatball Loaf".
Close-up of a sliced sausage pie with a golden-brown crust, showing a filling made of minced sausage and spices.
A close-up of a sliced stromboli, revealing its filling of cheese, meats, and vegetables, on a white plate. A sprig of fresh herbs is visible in the foreground.
Close-up of sliced spinach and pepperoni rolls arranged around a small bowl of marinara sauce on a white plate.
A bowl of wedding soup with meatballs, carrots, spinach, and small pasta in broth. Text reads "Momma's Wedding Soup.
A platter of various sliced pizza and specialty bread rolls with a bowl of marinara sauce in the background.
White pizzeria storefront with empty parking lot