Welcome Home to Great Cooking

Two New Castle Original Restaurants

“It’s not New York Pizza! It’s not Chicago Pizza!
It’s Mangino’s Pizza—and Real Italian Specialties!”

A close up of a pizza with cheese and meat

Home of Traditional Family Recipes

Dark red fork and knife icon on a black background.

Authentic Italian Comfort

Enjoy genuine Italian recipes crafted from family traditions.

A slice of pizza with three round toppings. The slice has a thick crust and is depicted using simple, solid colors.

Hand-Pinched Perfection

Savor our signature hand-pinched thick crust pizzas, perfected since 1979.

Icon of a red speech bubble with three white horizontal lines inside, resembling text.

Exclusive Menus at Each Location

Enjoy unique and specialty items tailored to each of our locations.

Signature Italian Delights

Mangino’s Pizzeria is your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine, offering a menu filled with classic pizzas, specialties, and Italian comfort food such as overstuffed Stromboli, pepperoni or spinach rolls, meatball loaf and more. Whether you're craving a quick grab-and-go meal or a family-style dining experience, we provide delicious, freshly made dishes that capture the essence of traditional Italian cooking.

A plate with hot dogs and rolls on it

Signature Italian Delights

Mangino’s Pizzeria is your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine, offering a menu filled with classic pizzas, specialties, and Italian comfort food such as overstuffed Stromboli, pepperoni or spinach rolls, meatball loaf and more. Whether you're craving a quick grab-and-go meal or a family-style dining experience, we provide delicious, freshly made dishes that capture the essence of traditional Italian cooking.

Our Locations

With two locations in New Castle, PA, Mangino’s Pizzeria offers unique dining experiences and Italian catering. Our Mahoningtown "Grab & Go Pizzeria" is perfect for a quick bite, while our Neshannock "Family-Style Pizzeria" invites families and teams to enjoy oversized banquette booths. Menus vary by location, so explore your options and visit us today!

Visit Us
A close up of a meatball sub sandwich
A bowl of soup with meatballs and vegetables.
A pepperoni pizza sitting on top of a table.
A close up of some food on top of a table
A close up of some sandwiches on a plate
A plate of food with some different types of sandwiches.

Neshannock: Family Style Pizzeria

A restaurant with a large sign on the front of it.

Neshannock: Family Style Pizzeria

Mahoningtown Grab & Go Pizzeria

A black and white photo of the front entrance to a restaurant.