Mahoningtown, New Castle, PA Catering Menu

Mahoningtown, New Castle, PA Catering Menu

Our Italian catered menu items are perfect for sporting events, social gatherings and parties. Real Italian comfort foods and recipes, made fresh with real ingredients to satisfy any size crowd. * Menu items and prices are subject to change without notice. Look for these ** that denote our Original Recipes!

106 N. Liberty St., New Castle, PA 16102 - (724) 652-7621

A platter of food with many different types of sandwiches.

CATERED ITALIAN SPECIALTY TRAYS

Take home our Italian favorites cut into bite-size slices to serve to friends and family. Served fresh from the oven, (hot-to-go) or boxed and chilled to reheat later. Perfect for sporting events, social gatherings and parties. Custom trays available upon request.

{ Classic Pizza & Specialty Tray } **

Hors d’ oeuvre Tray Selections: Classic Pizza, Poor Man’s Pizza, Pepperoni Rolls, Spinach Rolls, Stromboli, Sausage Pie.

Small (Serves 8-10)

61.95

Medium (Serves 12-14)

81.95

Large (Serves 18-20)

93.95
A piece of pie sitting on top of a wooden table.

Mangino's Sausage Pie

{ Whole Sausage Pie } **

Our very own sausage pie recipe that can be cut into twelve (12) slices or more and serve 10-12. Each slice is filled with mild Italian sausage, baked egg and melted REAL® Romano and Provolone cheeses, with a flavorful kick of Italian spices, crushed red pepper and fennel seeds.

12-Piece Tray

82.95

(Tray Serving Suggestion:
 Serve food at room temperature or place on oven tray and reheat for 8-10 minutes at 350 degrees.)

A plate of food that is on the table.

Party Sized Wings

{ Mangino’s Wings }

A party tray filled with chicken wings deep-fried to perfection and topped with the sauce of your choice. Comes with ranch dressing on the side.

Available in MILD, HOT, BBQ, and GARLIC sauce, or a variety of mix & matching flavors together.
TRY our NEW SWEET THAI CHILI sauce!

20-Piece Box

24.95

45-Piece Box

47.95

90-Piece Box

89.95
A bowl of meatballs and some rolls on the table

Classic Italian Trays

All served in party-sized heating trays with (12) boxed Garlic Knots.

{ Sausage, Onion, & Pepper Tray }

A party tray filled with grilled mild Italian sausage, caramelized onions and sliced bell peppers—an authentic Italian Festival tray.

Tray (Serves 8-10)

59.95

{ Mangino’s Meatball Tray } **

A party tray filled with two dozen (24) delicious meatballs served with Mangino’s Red Sauce. The classic meatball party tray.

Tray (Serves 10-12)

49.95
A bowl of soup with meatballs and vegetables.

Party-Sized Soups

{ Momma’s Italian Wedding } **

A party-sized soup filled with mini-meatballs, diced chicken breast, escarole, celery, carrots and pastina in a base of homemade chicken broth.

{ Chicken Pastina } **

A party-sized chicken pastina soup filled with diced chicken breast, celery, carrots and pastina in a base of homemade chicken broth.

Quart of Soup

12.20

Gallon of Soup

47.95
A plate of salad with tomatoes, lettuce and cheese.

Party Salad Trays

Choice of Dressing:
Mangino’s Balsamic**, Ranch, or Italian

{ Garden Salad Tray } **

Party tray of tender and crisp greens of romaine, market fresh tomatoes, sliced black olives, and REAL® Provolone cheese.

Tray (Serves 8-10)

31.95

{ Chef Salad Tray }

Party tray of tender and crisp greens of romaine lettuce, topped with black olives, tomatoes, shredded REAL® Provolone cheese, PrimA Porta Hot + Spicy Ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni and mild peppers.

Tray (Serves 8-10)

39.95

FAMILY-SIZED EXTRAS

{ Mangino’s Red Sauce } **

Mangino family’s sweetest secret—kept for over 75 years—our tomato sauce recipe. Perfect as a dipping sauce for our specialties, garlic knots and pasta trays!

Pint (16 oz)

5.50

Quart (32 oz)

10.95

{ Original Mangino’s Garlic Knots } **

Homemade bread knots brushed with Mangino’s Garlic Sauce and REAL® Romano cheese.

12 Knots

11.95
A burrito with some black olives on top of it.
A pile of cookies with different colored sprinkles.

FAMILY SIZE DESSERTS

{ Italian Cookie Tray }

Complete your party meal with a tray of assorted New York-style Italian cookies.

Small Tray – 3lbs

41.95

Large Tray – 4lbs

52.95

{ Cannoli Takeout Box }

Each box of crispy cannoli shells stuffed with a filling made from sweet creamy Ricotta blended with semi-sweet mini-chocolate chips and a dusting of powdered sugar to create an Italian favorite for your guests. Choose plain or chocolate cannoli shell.

Small Cannoli – 1/2 Dozen (6)

11.95

Small Cannoli – Dozen (12)

21.95

Large Cannoli – 1/2 Dozen (6)

26.95

Large Cannoli – Dozen (12)

49.95