A piece of cake sitting on top of a wooden table.

Our Promise

Mangino’s Pizzeria is committed to serving authentic Italian comfort food, prepared from cherished family recipes. Every dish, from our hand-pinched thick crust pizzas to traditional Italian meals, is crafted with care. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick bite, our menu brings the heart of Italy to your plate.

A series of photographs showing people in different locations.

Our Story

Mangino’s Pizzeria is an original hometown restaurant that was established in New Castle, Pennsylvania. The pizzeria was started by Charles Mangino Jr and Johanna Mangino in 1979. Mahoningtown is where they perfected their authentic Italian recipes. It was there that Chuck and Johanna worked side-by-side for many years refining their special hand-pinched pizza crust.

Over the years, Chuck and Johanna taught their children their craft and now Chailse, Brittany, and Michael are owners and operators of two Mangino’s Pizzeria locations.

In 2017, a second Mangino’s Pizzeria location was opened in Neshannock Township. This location is a restaurant style sit-down establishment.

As our Mangino family continues to grow- we all look forward to sharing with you a new generation of Mangino’s Pizzeria and the highest quality service and Italian specialties- from our original classics to our zucchini pizza, sausage pie, rolls, pasta homemade wedding soup and so much more!

A group of people holding pizza boxes and smiling.

Testimonials

Jake

Wonderful sit down pizza restaurant with slices ready to go..lots of options..the pepperoni and Buffalo chicken are my recommendations to and newbie

Isaiah

Wow... that was some of the best pizza I've ever had! The white sauce with tomatoes and spinach was phenomenal. Beautiful crust and genuine pizza for a decent price. I for sure will be back

Madeleine

Best veggie pizza I have ever eaten. Their crust is on point EVERY time and the staff is very friendly and welcoming.

If you are looking for some awesome, knowledgeable people to work with, these are the guys I highly recommend. Their friendliness and result-driven approach is what I love about them.

The BEST PIZZA in new castle

One of our favorite places to eat in the area! We recommended it to our friends and family!

Got a party tray for a birthday party and it was a big hit and enjoyed by everyone. People also enjoyed the marinara dipping sauce.

My husband and I had lunch here, so yummy! It was my husbands first time and he thought it was the best pizza he ever had!

The crust, the sauce, the dough, all of their toppings, we love it all!

Your sauce and all the food is so good. I love the Stromboli, I crave it ll the time!

I’m addicted to the whole menu! Mangino’s never disappoints. Delicious!

Mangino’s is the BEST of the best…ever! Totally unbelievable and the best wedding soup i’ve ever had.

The BEST veggie pizza I’ve ever eaten!! So darn YUMMY!

The Lasagna Pizza is the best!

A pizza sitting in a box on top of the floor.

Authentic Family Recipes

Discover our beloved family recipes at Mangino’s Pizzeria, featuring signature dishes like our original meatball loaf, homemade specialty pizzas, and overstuffed Stromboli. Enjoy hearty pepperoni or spinach rolls, fresh salads with our unique dressing, and our homemade Momma’s wedding soup. Each location offers these Italian comforts, though menu items and pricing may vary. Experience authentic Italian food made with Real® Cheeses, crafted by hand for true comfort and taste.

Taste and Comfort

At Mangino’s Pizzeria, we believe in hard work, quality, and community. With locations in Mahoningtown and Neshannock, we invite you to experience our Italian specialties. Whether you’re planning a family dinner, party, or event, our doors are open to serve you. Contact us for reservations or to discuss catering options.

A bowl of soup with meatballs and carrots.
A bowl of pasta covered in sauce and parmesan cheese.